If Healing Arts Had Been Around for the First Thanksgiving

This year, we celebrate Healing Arts' 20th anniversary. As Thanksgiving approaches, I thought it would be interesting to imagine the familiar story from a completely different perspective. What if Healing Arts had been around when the Pilgrims and Wampanoag came together for the first Thanksgiving in 1621 at Plymouth Colony?

Let's temporarily forget about turkey, stuffing, and pumpkin pie. This week, let's consider what these people experienced physically and emotionally, and how we could have healed them at Healing Arts.

-Dr. Alicia Armitstead

Dr. Alicia Armitstead meeting with the Pilgrims and Wampanoag at the first Thanksgiving

The Pilgrims had endured an exhausting Atlantic crossing followed by hunger, illness, exposure to harsh weather, enormous stress, and the challenge of surviving in an unfamiliar environment. The Wampanoag had a very different health history, including devastating epidemics that swept through Native communities before the Pilgrims established Plymouth.

If Dr. Armitstead could go back in time, what illness would she find and how could she use modern-day natural therapies to improve their health?


The Pilgrims: Exhaustion Would Have Been Just the Beginning


Imagine spending weeks aboard a crowded wooden ship and then arriving just as a New England winter was beginning.

By the time the Pilgrims began establishing their settlement, their bodies had been subjected to an extraordinary combination of physical and emotional stressors. Limited nutrition, disrupted sleep, cramped surroundings, physical exertion, severe weather, illness, and uncertainty could all take a toll.


Today, someone coming into our office after prolonged physical hardship might say: "I'm exhausted, and I don't feel like myself." But fatigue is a symptom, not an explanation.


Nutrition Response Testing is one of the tools Dr. Armitstead uses to evaluate a patient's physical and nutritional needs and develop a personalized nutritional program. Rather than looking at fatigue as an isolated complaint, the goal is to explore what the individual body may need for better support. For the Pilgrims, nutrition certainly would have been an interesting place to start.


Imagine the Aches and Pains


Next comes the physical toll. Weeks aboard ship, followed by the demanding work of establishing a settlement, could leave the body sore, stiff, and exhausted.


If a modern patient walked in with similar complaints, Dr. Armitstead could consider whether PEMF Therapy might be an appropriate modality for that individual. PEMF stands for Pulsed Electromagnetic Field. At Healing Arts NYC, it is one of our available wellness modalities for supporting the body and cellular function. It's fascinating to imagine what someone accustomed to life in 1621 would think if we showed them a modern PEMF device!


What About Their Respiratory Health?


Now imagine winter weather, close quarters, smoke, environmental changes, and illness. Respiratory discomfort and congestion would hardly be surprising.


Healing Arts NYC offers Halotherapy, also known as dry salt therapy, in our Salt Booth. Micronized salt is dispersed into the enclosed environment while the patient relaxes and breathes normally. Salt therapy is one of the modalities we use to support respiratory wellness, making it another fascinating modern-day contrast to the conditions people endured hundreds of years ago. Someone stepping off the Mayflower probably would have found sitting quietly in a salt room pretty appealing.


And Then There Was Stress


We sometimes underestimate how strongly prolonged stress can affect how we feel physically. Imagine leaving your home behind, spending weeks crossing an ocean, experiencing illness or loss around you, arriving somewhere unfamiliar, and then immediately facing the demands of survival.

There was no weekend off. No warm bed waiting at a hotel. And there certainly wasn't an opportunity to say, "I think I need a mental health day." Today we understand much more about the relationship between emotional stress and physical well-being.


Emotional Release Therapy at Healing Arts NYC is a gentle, body-based technique that helps the nervous system release stored emotional tension. Dr. Armitstead also incorporates other energy and mind-body modalities when appropriate for the individual. The circumstances are obviously very different today, but our bodies still respond to prolonged stress.

A Wampanoag sits inside The Himalayan Salt Booth

The Wampanoag and Unfamiliar Illness


European contact exposed the Wampanoag and other Native communities to infectious diseases their immune systems had little previous experience with. This lack of acquired immunity made unfamiliar illnesses especially dangerous. Their immune systems weren't weak. They were confronting infectious threats their bodies had not previously learned to recognize.


If these patients were recovering today, Dr. Alicia Armitstead could take a holistic approach to supporting their overall wellness.


  • Lymphatic Therapy could support lymphatic and circulatory function, while Halotherapy could support respiratory wellness.




  • The Himalayan Salt Booth could support the Wampanoag's lung and coughing issues and help boost their immune system through exposure to the Pilgrims.


The Wampanoag experience offers an important lesson: what our immune systems have encountered before can influence how our bodies respond to a new health threat.


If Only The Pilgrims and Wampanoag Had Online Access


Of course, we can't know exactly what each person sitting around the harvest gathering in 1621 was feeling. But let's imagine them with access to the same Holistic Symptom Checker you have access to today.


  • Fatigue?
  • Digestive problems?
  • Difficulty sleeping?
  • Aches and pains?
  • Stress?
  • Congestion?
  • Food sensitivities?


Instead of viewing these as completely separate problems, the Holistic Symptom Checker looks to see how they may be connected. Finding the root cause of symptoms is central to Dr. Armitstead's approach at Healing Arts NYC.


Something to Think About This Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving naturally reminds us to appreciate the people and things we sometimes take for granted. This year, perhaps we should add something unexpected to that list: How much we have learned about the human body.


We have access to knowledge, nutritional resources, technology, and wellness modalities that people living four centuries ago could never have imagined. Thankfully, none of us needs to cross the Atlantic aboard the Mayflower to get to Thanksgiving dinner.


But our bodies still have stories to tell. So while you're sitting around the table this Thanksgiving, take a moment to listen to yours. It might be telling you more than you realize.

On behalf of everyone at Healing Arts, we wish you all a safe and happy Thanksgiving.

Dr. Alicia Armitstead
Healing Arts NYC
(866) 585-5999

Please Share this Blog Post

Woman sitting on a bed by a window, looking out at a city skyline in soft morning light
By Dr. Alicia Armitstead • November 6, 2026
The Hidden Things Your Period Can Tell You About Your Health. The Clues Worth Paying Attention To
Woman lying in bed, awake and worried, with a glowing alarm clock reading 3:00 a.m.
By Dr. Alicia Armitstead • November 4, 2026
Why Do I Keep Waking Up in the Middle of the Night? If waking during the night has become your norm, it may be time to ask why your sleep keeps getting interrupted in the first place.
Preparing Your Body for the Holidays: Why January Healing Starts in November and December
By Dr. Aicia Armitstead • October 22, 2026
Preparing Your Body for the Holidays: Why January Healing Starts in November and December. How Holistic Testing Supports Holiday Health
Dr. Alicia Armitstead, with a sick patient, explains why more people get sick after summer ends
By Dr. Alicia Armitstead • October 14, 2026
Why More People Get Sick After Summer Ends: The Fall Sickness Patterns. Learn Why Fall Creates a Higher Risk of Getting Sick
Dr.Dr. Alicia Armitstead explains to a patient why frequent respiratory infections keep coming back
By Dr. Alicia Armitstead • June 9, 2026
Why Frequent Respiratory Infections Keep Coming Back.Understanding Recurrent Colds, Sinus Infections, and Bronchial Infections in an Urban Environment
Dr Alicia Armitstead is walking in Central Park with her two daughters
By Dr. Alicia Armitstead • April 4, 2026
Why Spring Makes Your Body Crave a Reset. How Seasonal Change Awakens Your Body’s Need for Renewal
Dr. Aicia Armitstead is listening to a patient with severe tension.
By Dr. Alicia Armitstead • April 4, 2026
Why Your Body Holds Tension Even When You Think You’re Relaxed. How Hidden Tension Disrupts Your Energy, Mood, and Digestion
Two people having a focused conversation in a softly lit, plant-filled office with framed floral art on the walls.
By Dr. Alicia Armitstead • April 4, 2026
The One Daily Habit That Quietly Drains Your Energy. How to Rebuild Your Energy by Listening to Your Body’s Early Signals
Dr. Alicia Armitstead is taking a Himalayan Salt Booth session
By Dr. Alicia Armitstead • March 5, 2026
Breathing Easier in the City: Natural Ways to Strengthen Your Lungs. Using Himalayan Salt Booth Therapy to Promote Clearer Breathing and Better Lung Function
A person consults with Dr. Alicia Armitstead, examining their neck; a tablet displays diagrams.
By Dr. Alicia Armitstead • March 5, 2026
What Your Skin Is Telling You About Your Gut, Liver, and Hormones. How Nutrition Response Testing Identifies the Internal Causes Behind Skin Symptoms